Discuss the social and cultural implications of displacement of communities in India.
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Displacement refers to shift in dwelling place, it may be forceful and involuntary, eg: displacement due to dam construction.
State induced displacement refers to the curious situation where state policies of development for one section causes displacement of other sector.
Government accountability for consequences have been absent, as highlighted by lacunae such as (Vasudha Dhagamwar):
1. Weak institutional framework for implementation of LARR (Land Acquisition and Rehabilitation Act) 2. Weak monetary benefits 3. No focus on emotional trauma caused 4. Unsatisfactory rehabilitation 5. Social-emotional cost of displacement not given attention 6. No compensation for loss of kinship ties, common property resources
Arundhati Roy - the displaced people are refugees of unacknowledged war, a heartbeat away from destitution.
Social implication of displaced communities
1. Walter Fernandez - 3 crore people displaced, 52% SC, 2% ST. Vulnerable population like SC/ST are more prone to displacement due to residence in forested areas (eg: Niyamgiri hills) 2. Loss of kinship bond = rise of nuclear settlement due to displacement 3. Women bear policies of relief and compensation (Mridula Singh), adding to vulnerability of girls, unmarried women, widows 4. Loss of identity - ethnic, linguistic 5. Imperfect integration to mainstream society, especially of tribals and forest dwellers (eg: high discrimination) 6. Loss of livelihood (traditional) - hunting, gathering, fishing, and rise of informal labour in mines (often causes detribalisation - Buddhadeb Khandhany) 7. Loss of political identity 8. Emotional trauma due to separation from totemic duties, forest, mountains (Guha and Gadgil) = ecological imperialism
Cultural implications
1. Loss of culture, eg: tribal culture of bride price, youth dormitory 2. Seepage of urban consumerist values in otherwise primitive people 3. Increased exploitation due to cultural transgression of dominant community 4. Marginalisation within economic sphere, coercively integrated to market economy 5. Not able to garner fruits of development, a feeling of discontent often bursts in form of ecological movements, via Lok Karo, Narmada Bachao
Thus displacement affects each and every aspect of people. Increasing quest for development leaves settled communities uprooted. This increases discontent. A proper policy of rehabilitation, according to EIA principles and consent based approach with Gram Sabha participation, are required. A concept of lesser ecological harm should also be there to protect communities.