Discuss the reasons behind manual scavenging in India and the solutions to end it.
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Manual scavenging is defined as the act of lifting human excreta by humans. This evil is present in Indian society still, despite frameworks like ban on manual scavenging.
Reasons behind manual scavenging
1. Caste problem: MOSJE shows that 98% of scavengers belong to SC/ST only, and rest 2% from backward caste. Discrimination, prejudice and stereotype perpetuate such acts by low caste who are made to serve high caste. This problem is historical 2. Lack of livelihood to people who accept manual scavenging work for a penny 3. Low legal standards and poor legislative frameworks, eg: there is not a single conviction under prevention of manual scavenging law (MOSJE) 4. Apathy of government - despite numerous incidents of death due to poisonous gases inside sewers, government at helm continues to say that there had been '0' deaths due to scavenging 5. Poverty - breeding low skill and lack of employability pushes people to scavenging 6. Faulty urbanisation - faulty drainage limiting cleaning through machines requires human intervention 7. Apathy of society - weak institutional mechanism of municipalities who themselves hire such people at low wage, even without wage
Solutions for manual scavenging
1. Raising awareness about caste discrimination and hardship suffered by low caste people to evoke sympathy 2. Tighter legal framework -> punishment/penalty for employing to manual scavenging 3. Technological solutions -> efficient drainage design, construction of dry latrines, construction of bio toilets, using robotic arm for sewer clearance, eg: Bandicoot robots in Kerala made the state free from manual scavenging 4. Emergency procedure - if at all men have to enter the manhole, they must be provided protective equipments such as oxygen mask, PPE kits 5. Improving position, i.e fiscal, and staff of municipalities to ascertain effective management of drainage system 6. New employment creation through training (PM Kaushal Vikas Yojana) and rehabilitation (compensation - 10 lakh, Supreme Court) 7. NAMASTE - action plan for mechanised sewerage (ecosystem cleaning) 8. Participation of NGOs/CSOs to identify the instances of such activities
Thus as Gandhiji said, "everyone should become his own scavenger", can be a source of light to fight this menace through community participation approach.