Discuss the debate around criminalising marital rape in India.
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Marital rape, as defined under the Independent Thought case, refers to non-consensual sex between a husband and wife, if a wife is less than 18 years of age.
Justice Verma Committee recommended for criminalising of marital rape, which got credence for Supreme Court judgement (IPC - Article 375).
Effects of marital rape criminalisation
1. It would lead breakdown of families (frequently in India), where family is important social institution 2. It would lead rise of single parent, parentless child 3. It can be misused against husbands, by women for economic benefits 4. It would reduce the sanctity of marriage in India, where man and woman are treated as a single entity after marriage (doctrine of coverture) 5. It would lead to vulnerability of children, affect their careers, ingrain in them emotional trauma
However there are some positive sides also:
1. Uphold dignity and sovereignty of women 2. Provide women freedom from toxic relationships, help their social-economic empowerment 3. Uphold her right to life (Article 21) guaranteed by constitution
Thus a more balanced approach is required, eg. bringing gender neutrality in marital rape law, social sensitization about women rights.
"A raped woman lives with horror of rapist A marital raped woman lives with rapist"