Discuss the need for private sector participation in Indian education and the concerns it raises.
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Francis J Brown defines education as systematic skilling of pupil which leads to universal attitude cultivation, and provides an atmosphere for development.
Indian education system is both prerogative of government as well as private institutions.
Government policies like:
1. Right to Education - for universal enrollment, universal retention 2. Scholarships such as -> STEM scholarship, WEST scholarship 3. Inclusivity - PWDs, SC/ST, 25% enrollment in private colleges
Private sector participation
Private sector participates in primary and secondary schools. India spends only 3% of GDP on education, thus arises need of private participation in education:
1. To upgrade syllabus in line with industrial requirement 2. To improve teacher's ability, teacher training, reduce teacher absenteeism 3. For higher school infrastructure as government schools lack many facilities 4. To induce competitiveness in education market to introduce higher quality primary and secondary education 5. Private sector would help in increasing seats for MBBS, Btech and improve employability (NSSO, 47% of engineers unemployable) 6. Private sector with high financial capacity could introduce better facilities like online education, open courses, certifications 7. Can help in linkage of industry and academia to improve practicability of education through innovation 8. Provide world class facilities like Ryan International School, Amity University
However these have concerns:
1. Increasing commercialisation of education (high entrance/education fee) 2. Impacts inclusivity of education, as government provides reservation to vulnerable people 3. Would lead to capitalistic value transfer in student as education will promote sole profit motive 4. Increasing private participation in engineering colleges have resulted in decrease in quality of such courses 5. Instances of corruption/donations/seat selling in higher educational institutes 6. May promote coaching culture to garner profit among students preparing for graduation 7. Could lead to digital divide, rural-urban divide, as most private institutions prefer high class urban areas like Delhi, Mumbai for their campus 8. Also impacts employment opportunities for teaching class in private educational institutions 9. Issues of faulty syllabus, fake accreditation, poor assessment mars private colleges
Thus need is to follow accommodative approach as highlighted in New Educational Policy of 2020.