Topper Copies

Discuss regionalism in India as both a threat to and a partner of nationalism.

Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023

Harihar Bhattacharya defines regionalism as geographic concentration of loyalties encouraged through caste/class, region and religion.

It is defined as when love for region is greater than love for nation.

Regionalism as a threat

1. Causes demands from various groups ranging from: - Separate state -> Telangana, Jharkhand - Secessionist -> Khalistan - State autonomy -> Ladakh 2. It gives a death blow to national integrity as it increases parochial tendencies 3. Various groups based on caste/creed etc are pitted against one another, like the issue of Kannadigas versus Tamilians in sharing of Cauvery water 4. It breaks down the law and order, causing mass killings and ethnic conflicts (eg: Nagalism demands) 5. Regionalism can be used to fan nationalism (Jharkhand, Odisha) by highlighting the issue of underdevelopment and heightening feeling of exploitation. It would lead to Balkanisation of country, causing numerous political/social and economic tensions 6. Regionalism is further strengthened by history, myths, folklore

Causes for regionalism -> caste, class, language, religion, and diversity in lopsided development

However regionalism is not always a disintegrating force:

1. Deepankar Gupta - says that regionalism is not anti-people or anti-national. However it becomes problematic only when interest of one region is put diametrically opposite to other 2. Rajni Kothari - is optimistic about regionalism. He says that regionalism promotes development of a region, and nationalism promotes development of nation, hence both can exist in a creative partnership 3. Michael Harrington says that regionalism is a precursor to nationalism. What starts as regionalism would culminate into nationalism 4. Regionalism has made India's electoral space more vibrant, with increased participation of population as well as increased regional political parties 5. Issues of region - lopsided development, fiscal devolution, district identity - have been raised at national level 6. It fulfilled the aspiration of people by formation of new states (Jharkhand, Telangana) along with unity maintained 7. A distinct religio-linguistic identity further strengthened national identity

Thus regionalism has helped to realise local/regional goals which ultimately led to national development. It has stood the test of time, and its success depends on accommodative approach.