Durkheim's evolutionary theory of the division of labour, mechanical and organic solidarity, and its critics.
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Emile Durkheim is concerned with the problem of chaos and uncertainty in post-French Revolution time. He asks "How does society remain integrated through a course of war and chaos?" His theory of "division of labour" (DOL) is a quest to answer the above question.
He sees DOL in a social term and cites it as a social fact, at a time when it was established as an economic fact (Adam Smith). DOL means breaking up a task between different individuals to increase efficiency.
Durkheim's view on DOL
He sees DOL as an evolutionary perspective, contrasting ancient and modern societies.
*Ancient societies* - High mechanical solidarity due to likeliness: less population, so less material density; less interaction, so less moral density. - Labour equally divided, low production, huge food available, production techniques known by all. - Religious society - norms repressive - no innovation.
*Modern society*
This gives high organic solidarity.
Thus in modern society, which is heterogenous: 1. Huge competition about occupations. 2. People specialise in occupation and the fittest survive in it. 3. Rest of the people create other occupations and specialise in them. 4. This process continues, and DOL is realised.
He sees DOL as integrative, as one person is dependent on others in the course of occupation. However he also accepts that it can be dysfunctional in the form of: 1. Anomic DOL - causing alienation. 2. Forced DOL - talent and ability mismatch. 3. Inefficient DOL - fruitless DOL in the wrong direction.
Durkheim gives solutions for such dysfunctions: 1. Overhaul of the production process, by integrating workers organically to their work. 2. Professional association could help. 3. Code of conduct and ethics, to replace self-interest.
Thus Durkheim, though he gave dysfunctions, considered it a mere pathological state due to normlessness. He himself says, in the context of 18th century Europe, "the norm is disturbed and new norm can't be evolved immediately," and considers it a transitory stage.
The Marxian conflict perspective to DOL adds dynamism to the concept, and the world-system view by Wallerstein highlights the coercive nature of DOL.