Merton's neofunctionalist critique of structural functionalism, through his three postulates and the idea of dysfunction.
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
R.K. Merton was a neo-functionalist. He modified the existing structural functionalism by adding his concepts of latent and manifest functions, middle range theories (MRT) and deviance.
Merton's role 1. Highlighted the inefficiencies of the existing approach, such as broad theories with little practical usefulness. 2. Made structural functionalism more descriptive, analytical, by modifying it into neo-functionalism. 3. Expanded scope to study meaning by actors, both intended and unintended.
Merton's critique of structural functionalism
1. He introduced the concept of manifest function (intended by the actor, subjective disposition, the actor is aware of it) and latent function (unintended, not perceived by the actor, established objectively by the investigator). Further, Merton's paradigm holds that a latent function branches into dysfunctions and non-functions, and a dysfunction can suggest a functional alternative.
2. He rejected earlier postulates of conventional structural functionalism: - Postulate of functional unity: Merton says that a social item may be dysfunctional in one context and functional in another, eg: slavery functional in feudal society, not in modern society. - Postulate of functional indispensability: Merton says that alternative institutions exist for performing functions, eg: creches for child care, school for education, police for social control. - Postulate of functional universalism: Merton says it is not that every item is always functional only because it exists, eg: caste, though it exists, is not functional - without caste India would be a much better social setup. 3. Merton provides middle range theories to solve day-to-day problems. MRT (middle range theories) are a triple alliance of data, theory, method.
Thus he bridges MRT between raw empiricism and grand theory with no practical use. Merton thus provides for dysfunctions as well as non-functions, and freed structural functionalism from the critique of overlooking the conflict caused by an item. He also combines the psychological aspect with the structural aspect in his theory of deviance.