Topper Copies

Is caste a phenomenon unique to Hindu society, or does it manifest in other societies and religions as well? (20 marks)

Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023

Caste is an endogamous group with its root in the Varna (broad) framework. Its reality is "Jati", which is the actual interacting group.

The caste system is peculiar to India, and is said to have a divine origin, based on religious myths (Manusmriti); its exact origin, however, is unknown.

However, it is manifested in many other forms, like:

1) South Africa Blacks, whites: the system of apartheid kept blacks (majority in numbers) oppressed and dominated by white minorities.

Disabilities imposed on them - higher taxes - not to roam in streets after 9 pm - no right to vote - reside in particular places, leading to ghettoisation

2) In Muslims Ghaus Ansari describes 4 stratas in Muslims. These stratas in Muslims are comparable to Indian caste.

These were comparable to Indian Jatis, with Ashraf compared to high caste Muslims, and Ajlaf consisting of converts, and Arzals were the disprivileged sections.

The effect of close association with Hinduism created such a contradiction, opposed to the equality tenet of Islam.

3) In Christianity Caste system manifests itself on 2 accounts: due to contacts with Hinduism, and due to their own classification:

"In Christianity, caste system is based on sect, location and characteristics of predecessors."

- Brahmin converts = Bamman Christ (Namboodiris and Nairs) - Vaishya converts = Chardos - Shudra converts = Sudirs - Untouchable converts = at the lowest rungs (Chamars)

Latin Christians in India practiced untouchability to maintain their superiority, since British times.

Thus there were different types of casteist organisation structures in different societies.

Their similarity with Hinduism 1. Imposition of disabilities on the lowest caste people, in terms of ritual/civic/cultural and habitat segregation 2. Conforming to the model of hierarchy of caste, based on domination and subdomination, eg: cremation grounds in Kerala are segregated for upper caste and Dalit converts

Dissimilarity 1. In the caste system of India (Hinduism and Varna), it is sanctioned by traditional literature; however, in Islam and Christianity, they were originally equal societies 2. It is the effect of Hinduism, i.e close association with Hinduism since medieval times (Islam) and British time (Christianity), that led to such a caste system 3. The Indian caste system is based on the notion of pollution and purity; however, this concept is not original to other societies

Thus there are systemic differences between the caste system around the world.