How has modernisation brought about changes in India's social structure and value system? (20 marks)
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Yogendra Singh defines modernisation as a cultural process which is rational in thought, based on universalistic ideologies, secularism etc.
Modernisation is the adoption of secular values that are culturally neutral. It induces changes in social structure and values.
Modernisation: changes in social structure
1. Changes in family - role of family in mate selection has diminished, leading to a rise of nuclear family (Yogendra Singh) and a rise of the no-kids family (DINK, double income no kids) - eg: online dating, love marriage 2. Changes in caste structure - diminishing notion of pollution and purity; caste limited to the private sphere (eg: Harold Gould's study of Lucknow rickshawallas) - class-based stratification more important than caste-based stratification (Andre Beteille) 3. Changes in marriage - rise of inter-caste, inter-religion marriage - live-in relationships, same-sex marriage - divorce and widowhood no longer hold stigma and are acceptable by society - new concept of "wifehood" (greater conjugal bond strength than kinship) (Raj Gandhi) 4. Changes in religion - MN Srinivas, in his study of Coorgs, says that people of Coorg have moved to secular beliefs; the ritual sphere no longer dominates their life - similarly, Andre Beteille, in his study of Sripuram village, says that the people of Tanjore respond less to ritual beliefs 5. Changes in kinship: Willmott and Young's concept of role bargaining, i.e maintaining relationship only with a few; strong kinship bonds are replaced by friends, colleagues and co-workers in modern cosmopolitan culture 6. Changes in the patriarchal system, women - western dressing, increase in women's participation in employment - inheritance rights given, sexual independence, taking part in reproductive and marriage decisions etc 7. Change in class structure: the caste-class nexus is broken down; caste does not dictate class, rather economic and political power dictates class (TB Bottomore); swelling of the middle class leads to consumerist behaviour and higher aspiration to mobility 8. Change in value system
| Modern values have replaced | Traditional values | |---|---| | Individualism | Collectivism | | Stratification | Hierarchy | | This-worldly attitude | Other-worldly attitude | | Innovation | Status quo | | Mobility | Conservationist | | Achievement oriented, rights and entitlement | Ascription oriented society | | Particularistic attitude | Universalistic attitude |
However, the modernisation process is not yet complete, as Andre Beteille says that India has gone for "segmentary modernisation", as the lifestyle of modernity is adopted, but interpersonal relationships, eg between caste and class hierarchy, are still not modern.