Marx's and Weber's theories of religion, compared.
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Ronald Robertson defines religion as a process concerned with supernatural that has a governing effect on us. It is a system of beliefs and practices related to a sacred thing, kept apart and forbidden, which unite all in a single moral community called church (Durkheim).
Max Weber and Karl Marx both viewed religion from different perspectives.
| Max Weber | Karl Marx | |---|---| | 1. He viewed religion as playing a creative role | 1. He put forth the conflict perspective to study religion | | 2. Religion promotes the spirit of capitalism by giving beliefs about work is worship, predestination, god created the world for his own glory. He exemplified this in his Protestant Ethic and Spirit of Capitalism (PE&SC) | 2. Religion is termed the "opium of the masses." The capitalist uses it to suppress the "have nots." He says that Christianity was a struggle against the Roman empire; often religious and capitalistic heads collude together and give legitimacy to each other in suppressing have nots | | 3. He studies religions of many capitalistic countries like India, Japan etc and differentiates between the nature of capitalism - in India it is forced capitalism, whereas in Japan it is ritualistic capitalism | 3. He says that religion makes a false impression that power lies in the supernatural. The reality is that power lies in people | | 4. He says religious factors help in industrialisation; cultural factors help in mobility of persons | 4. Marx is antagonistic about religion. He sees religion as justifying the oppression of people | | 5. Weber does not see any end of religion in capitalist society | 5. Marx says that in communism, religion will end as the factor producing it would end | | 6. Weber sees religion and capitalism compatible with each other, in a creative partnership | 6. Marx sees religion as a way of oppression only |
Thus both the scholars have different views about religion. Marx links religion's rise to the same factors which lead to the rise of capitalism, thus says as capitalism ends in communism, religion would also end. He sees secularism as a decline of religion itself, whereas for Weber it means decreasing presence of religiosity and emergence of alternative institutions like sects and cults.