How does AR Desai explain the growth of Indian nationalism from a Marxist perspective? (20 marks)
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
AR Desai's seminal work "Social Background of Indian Nationalism" (SBIN) analyses the growth of Indian nationalism through different stages, in terms of mass base, feudalism and capitalism.
AR Desai was a doctrinaire Marxist, and his concept of Indian nationalism was opposed to the nationalist perspective.
1. AR Desai saw the reform movements initiated during the 1800s by Raja Ram Mohan Roy and his comrades as the beginning of Indian nationalism. He says that Ram Mohan Roy was the pioneer of reform movements in India, and without such reform movements nationalism could not have taken root, against the perspective of nationalists that nationalism was always present, even before the British arrival.
2. He says that Indian nationalism arose as an outcome of material contradictions created by the British economic-political system (a single law and order, the disappearance of Jajmani and the jural power of Panchayats).
3. In his work on peasant struggle in India, he says that the peasants' struggle was against the rising capitalism of those times. The contradiction between the old value system and the new economic system led to many socio-reform movements, like - Roy's Brahmo Samaj movement against Sati, propagating widow remarriage - similarly, the Satyashodhak Samaj movement to uplift the Shudras' position
AR Desai also differentiates between the reformist and the revivalist movements. To him, Arya Samaj was a revivalist movement, whereas Brahmo Samaj was a reformist movement.
4. He says that the Indian national struggle, which drew on the lines of socio-religious reform movements, was never mass-based, as leaders like Nehru and Gandhi did not adopt plans and policies to uplift the masses. Rather, they glorified nationalism in the heart and mind of the utterly poor to further their own interest, i.e to shift power and control from external colonisers to internal colonisers.
5. He saw peasant society as marked by the supra-landlordism of the British, who appointed sub-landlords. Thus the British thesis and the peasant anti-thesis led to revolts of peasants, such as the Pabna revolt, Narkelbera revolt etc.
6. AR Desai says that the peaceful and bloodless approach adopted by the Indian freedom struggle was a solace given to the privileged bourgeoisie class, that their interests would not be jeopardised even temporarily.
7. He referred to the Indian National Congress as a bourgeois organisation which encouraged the middle class to fight against the British.
Thus his theory of Indian nationalism constantly reflects a dialectical process of thesis and antithesis. However he was criticised for taking such a view, by nationalists who term his theory as ideologically biased.