How does Andre Beteille's study of Sripuram village explain social stratification in India? (20 marks)
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Andre Beteille employs the interactionist perspective, drawing from the Weberian, trinitarian concept of stratification, dependent on caste, class and power.
His work on Sripuram village in Tanjore shows his use of a multi-causal stratification theory.
1. He criticises Louis Dumont for taking caste as the only basis for stratification. 2. In his study of Sripuram village, he identifies that along with caste, class (wealth) and power (political association) defined stratification. 3. He contends that in Sripuram there is an intra-caste hierarchy among Brahmins: Smartha Brahmin, Vaishnav Brahmin, having sub-castes based on wealth and power. 4. Criticising Louis Dumont's pollution and purity notion, he says that non-Brahmans in Sripuram call themselves Adi-Dravidians, to delink themselves from Brahmans. 5. In his analysis he states that:
| Previously | After | |---|---| | Brahmins had cumulative stratification (+,+,+) in terms of caste, class, power: high-caste Brahmans also had land ownership, education and considerable income from other sources. They had links with cities, which enhanced their prestige. Whereas Adi-Dravidians had no land, no education (-,-,-), and suffered cumulative inequality | After transportation and communications increased, in course Brahmans migrated to cities for white-collar jobs and sold their lands. Many Adi-Dravidians purchased land, and hence the ownership organisation of the village changed |
Now Adi-Dravidians too owned land; in the meantime they also started getting educated, and many Adi-Dravidians were employed in cities as white-collar labourers, competing with Brahmans even.
6. He also wrote the "Pollution and Poverty" essay, and said that poverty is more contagious than pollution, in response to Dumont's ideology of pollution and purity. 7. He also focuses on the socio-economic aspect of caste, such as power and class, which had been overshadowed by more emphasis on the cultural perspective. 8. He says that it is important to understand the relationship between upper caste and lower caste, landless and land-owning, and other entities like kinship (which has an effect on caste-based occupation) and gender. 9. Criticising Yogendra Singh, he says that though cumulative inequality has been replaced by dispersed inequality, India is still not modern, and "caste has developed cracks only". 10. He also contradicts Louis Dumont's view that caste is always ascriptive. He gives examples like Ravidas, Guru Nanak etc, who were not priestly by birth but still worshipped.
Thus, in the prevailing paradigm of "caste" and its cultural implications, Andre Beteille developed a deep understanding, with his three-fold classification on the basis of class, caste and power.