How have land reforms changed the class and power balance in Indian agriculture since independence? (20 marks)
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Post-independence, land reforms were the main thrust to change the faulty agrarian structure. Land reforms changed the ownership, class organisation as well as power balance in the agricultural sector.
Some land reforms 1. Zamindari abolition 2. Tenancy reforms: rent regularisation, fixity of tenure, ownership rights 3. Land ceiling 4. Land consolidation 5. Agriculture cooperativisation 6. Homestead rights 7. Land record modernisation
Cause of change in power balance 1. Zamindari abolition brought 200 lakh farmers into direct contact with government; this gave them freedom from the intermediaries that mined their exploitation 2. Rise of backward class ownership: Zoya Hasan says that backward class ownership swelled post land reforms, rising to 38% (1996) from 8% 3. Rise of a strong middle class in the agrarian structure: many progressive farmers competed for change in power and status in the village (Andre Beteille: progressive farmers) 4. Migration: caused a rise of landless labourers working in the fields of rich/big farmers
However, negative effects like an increase in landlessness (up to 11.6% in 1992) also brought a rise of peasant proletarianisation (PC Joshi).
5. Land ceiling and redistribution helped decrease land concentration in a single hand. Over 2.2 million hectares was distributed among 5.5 million beneficiaries 6. Operation Barga in Bengal led to 41% of land being brought under the direct ownership of tenants 7. Homestead rights decreased homelessness among peasants
Thus, the change in land ownership, land use etc changed the power balance in villages.
Effects of such change (land reform) 1. Khusro, in his study, states that land was forcefully taken and peasants forcefully evicted, however shown as voluntary surrender on records 2. Social conflict: in regions like Bihar, the dominant owner class resisted land ceiling and consolidation; Ranveer Sena, Diamond Sena etc were spread to oppose reforms 3. AR Desai/Joshi summarises land reform effects in these ways - decrease in hereditary ownership - rise of owner farmer - increase in commercial/contract farming - proletarianisation of peasants - exploitative land lease started 4. Social inequalities and disharmony among castes made agriculture cooperativisation a non-starter 5. Political collusion: bureaucratic collusion with rich farmers increased, to evade land ceiling 6. Rise of benami transactions 7. Laxminarayana says that "paper divorce" to evade land ceiling sowed the seed of separate living
Thus, land reforms were a mixed bag of changes and effects. Further, the coming up of the 74th amendment, Panchayats etc have again altered caste-class power, with space opening for the hitherto unprivileged.