What were the contending views on integration versus autonomy of tribals in India? (10 marks)
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Tribals, constituting 8.6% of the total population, do not fit into a one-size category. Based on the diversity among tribes, the Constituent Assembly debated their integration into society or their autonomy.
Two strands emerged. It is difficult to synthesise them, as both reflect conflicting paradigms.
| Integration of tribals | Autonomy of tribals | |---|---| | GS Ghurye, on the basis of integration to society, calls tribals "backward Hindus" due to imperfect integration in Hindu society. He divides tribal society into 3 sections: (1) Raj Gonds, high status, fully hinduised tribes (2) partially hinduised (3) hill sections, no integration | Verrier Elwin: "we do not want to keep tribals as a museum, but at the same time want the development clock to show the same time for them." He preferred autonomy for tribals, to protect their culture, values and belief |
2. Integration on lines of the caste-tribe continuum, to increase development: DN Majumdar called for controlled integration 3. Integration along the peasant-tribe continuum: Surajit Sinha, as a response to the necessity of peasants for cheap labour - Guha and Gadgil talked about ecological imperialism, due to the reserving of forest and produce - LP Vidyarthi said that separation from the forest was not only economic but emotional also, as forest, trees etc have totemic importance to tribes
After independence, the Tribal Panchsheel was adopted, for controlled integration as well as autonomy. - Tribal isolation was termed colonial baggage - Development was given focus through: respecting their culture, providing them land rights, training them for forest maintenance, not over-administering but helping them evolve through their own genius
Thus, successful models like Arunachal Pradesh today have well-integrated tribals with high socio-economic development.