Topper Copies

Weber's ideal type of bureaucracy and its benefits for a diverse country like India.

Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023

Max Weber describes bureaucracy as the highest degree of legal-rational authority. It is an ideal type in modern industrialised and capitalistic country, true for India also.

Benefit of bureaucratic structure 1. Max Weber says that bureaucracy has a higher order of degree, precision, and reliability as compared to other structures, hence it helps in coping with huge administrative set up. 2. Stewart Clegg also says that bureaucracy is inevitable in modern capitalistic countries and is higher ethics oriented. In India those ethics like honesty, probity, integrity help in proper policy formulation and implementation. 3. Paul du Gay says that bureaucracy treats everyone equal. Hence neutral (political neutrality) decision making helps in objective goal realisation in India.

Challenges 1. Elite capture and power usurpation, as Vincent de Gournay says - rise of bureau mania. 2. High handedness attitude, with less approachability, and lack of contact with masses (Honore de Balzac calls this genit power weilding pygmies). 3. Reduction to a cog in machinery without creativity - leads to goal displacement, as Merton says. 4. High focus on rule-regulation creates apathetic attitude towards people.

Thus bureaucracy, as Max Weber says, suffers from loss of creativity, however a proper accountability system can restore it.