Topper Copies

Why are Dalit Christians and Dalit Muslims demanding reservation, and what challenges does this raise? (10 marks)

Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023

Minorities like Dalit Christians and Dalit Muslims, i.e Dalits (untouchables) converted to the Muslim fold and Christianity, have been demanding reservation, which is presently given only to Dalits converted to Buddhism.

Reasons for such demand 1. Discrimination in the public employment sphere based on caste 2. Historic disabilities suffered by Dalits, which made them vulnerable in the present 3. For socio-economic development, as most Dalits are still employed in low rungs of occupation (manual scavenging) and are landless 4. To reach parity with Dalits converted to Buddhism 5. For increasing their voice politically and socially

Challenges 1. Increasing caste consciousness, due to reservations 2. Prompts other backward castes like Jats, Kunbis to ask for reservation 3. Violates the principle of equality and meritocracy 4. Andre Beteille says that reservations increase - pathological division of labour - violation of the spirit of the constitution focusing on historic wrongs rather than present wrongs 5. Issues of - overinclusion (fake caste certificates) - underinclusion (data unavailability) - non-inclusion (unawareness, extreme backwardness) 6. Risk for the political sphere, such as opportunistic politics and identity politics for votebank, causing secessionist tendencies

Recently Pasmanda Muslims demanded reservation; however, educational skilling and training are the areas which need immediate focus to increase development of minorities.