Topper Copies

Compare and contrast the perspective of Andre Beteille and M.N Srinivas with respect to 'study of caste'.

Yaksh Chaudhary, AIR 6, 2021

MN Srinivas studied caste through structural-functional perspective while Andre Beteille used the weberian Trinitarian paradigm to analyse caste system in the society.

Similarity between Both 1. Mobility in caste system Both see that caste system is mobile. MN Srinivas in his Rampura Village study argued that secular hierarchy based on landownership, numerical strength is becoming important. It has given rise to "dominant caste" in villages (Ex- Lingayats, Reddys). Sanskritisation as a way of cultural imitation was also an instruement for social mobility in caste system. Andre Beteille in his study of Tanjore village also give importance to secular parameters. He argues that employment, land and political power has given fluidity to the caste system. 2. Interdependence of caste MN Srinivas argues that with changes in the society, the jajmani system is weakening. Andre Beteille also argues that Brahmins of Tanjore were seeking employment outside village. The empowerment of lower castes through income and political power is undermining the jajmani system. 3. Importance to Economic factors MN Srinivas advocates that the landownership, enhanced income from urban areas etc. has improved the status of few castes and they have become dominant in the village. Similarly Andre Beteille also argues that classes have not cutting across the status groups (i.e. castes). The Congruity between caste and class is breaking down. 4. Both see caste as a system of status (MN Srinivas emphasise on ritual status while Beteille on honor).

Difference between both 1. MN Srinivas give larger importance to caste as a system of hierarchy. While Beteille gives equal importance to caste, class and power. 2. MN Srinivas gives importance to integrative nature of caste system while Beteille Considers it as disjunctive. 3. MN Srinivas uses concepts of Brahiminisation and Sanskritisation to explain ritual mobility of caste system, while Beteille ignored this aspect. 4. According to MN Srinivas, Untouchables have very little chances of upward mobility (Hinduised/Brahminic view). While Beteille do not Considers so and advocate equal opportunities for all castes.

Hence both see caste system as an important institution of Indian villages. Both see it as related to status differentiation and segmentary in nature. However they defined mobility in it through different perspectives and paradigms.