Secularization of caste is essentially a modern phenomenon. Discuss.
Yaksh Chaudhary, AIR 6, 2021
Secularisation of caste means that the religious sanctions (Ghurye) behind the caste system are fading. Along with this, the rigid hierarchy of the caste system is also becoming open and mobile.
1. With modernisation, the empowerment of different caste is happening. Dipankar Gupta argues that the empowerment of lower castes has led to horizontal differentiation of castes and muddled hierarchies. 2. The ritual factors are loosing dominance in forming the caste hierarchy. MN Srinivas in his "Social change in modern India" explains that the secular hierarchy through political and economic power is undermining the ritual hierarchy. 3. According to Andre Beteille, with more economic empowerment and modernisation, the congruence between the caste, class and power is disintegrating. Hence secular features also decide the hierarchy now. 4. Louis Dumont through his "substantialisation of caste" concept explains how different caste are becoming independent and impenetrable blocks and hierarchy is undermined. 5. Dalit Conciousness is increasing and Dalits and OBCs are demanding their rights.
However, Harold Gould in his Rikshawallah's study of Lucknow says that caste rituals are still dominant in private sphere. Sukhdeo Thorat and Ghanshyam Shah also argue that caste system still prevails in 80% of villages.
Hence secularisation of caste is happening under influence of many factors.