India's Nationalism was the result of the material conditions created by the British Colonialism. Examine the statement with respect to AR Desai's work.
Yaksh Chaudhary, AIR 6, 2021
AR Desai analysed the background of nationalism in India through marxist and dialectical material paradigm. He examined this in his book "The Social Background of Indian Nationalism".
AR Desai argues that Indian Nationalism was a product of Colonialism by British. It was produced by the material Conditions formed by the Britishers. He criticised the view of other scholars (Nationalist thinkers) who advocated that Nationalism was present even before advent of Britishers.
Britishers introduced the new land policy and enhanced the land tax rate. It led to emergence of many new classes of zamindars, moneylenders, absentee landlords etc. These classes exploited the poor peasants and sharecroppers. Hence this exploited class started struggle against the Britishers and zamindars.
The new administrative system by Britishers based on discrimination was introduced. Educated people not finding employment (i.e. middle class) started the national movement.
The industrial class also faced the discriminatory practices of Colonial rulers through discriminatory custom duty, freight charges vis-a-vis Indian and foreign industrialists. All these material Conditions fuelled the emergence of Indian National movement.
AR Desai's five stages of the national movement 1. Till 1905: sporadic incidents of struggle with local issues happened. No central leadership was there. Small social base of these struggles was there. 2. 1905-1905: Indian National Congress (INC) was formed by the disenchanted middle classes to serve their interests and also awaken the masses. New Bourgeoise class also joined movement. 3. 1905-1919: extremis increased by disillusionment of moderate politics. lower middle classes also joined. Due to swadeshi push, industrial class also supported it. 4. 1919- Civil disobedience movement: masses, working class, women also joined the movement. The organised workers movement under AITUC and Communism under CPI (1925) also started. 5. 1930-1947: dissent with Gandhian methods, socialism started to gain importance, depressed class movement started by Ambedkar.
AR Desai argues that the leadership of National movement remained under the hand of bourgeoise and middle classes. The production relations encouraged the growth of National movement.
Yogendra Singh criticised AR Desai on being failed to provide any substantive evidence to support his theory and neglection of other factors other than material factors.
Hence AR Desai sees the roots of India National movement in the material and productions relations formed by the Britisher Colonialists.