Topper Copies

The idea of the Indian village as represented in the earlier writings of the colonial administrators has been critiqued by many scholars. Discuss.

Yaksh Chaudhary, AIR 6, 2021

Colonial administrators and scholars have vested political and social interests and accordingly they represented an image of Indian villages which suited those interests of maintaining their power and hegemony.

fig. idea of Indian villages by Britishers

However this indological and book view of early British administrators like Henry maine, Baden Powell was criticised by field studies of many scholars.

1. Self sufficiency of villages MN Srinivas argued that villages were having relationships with other villages through village exogamy, pilgrimages etc. He studied Rampura village in his study "The Remembered Village". Similarly Andre Beteille in his study of Sripuram village of Tanjore explains how villages had social networks spread outside village. SC Dube, Ghurye also criticised the self-sufficient image. 2. Village Patroitism Adron myer gave this concept. MN Srinivas criticised it as while villages have unity but this unity through village patroitism is occasional and not always present. FG Bailey in Bisipara village study suggest that villages have many cleavages through caste system and status. Hence village unity is not possible. Similarly Andre Beteille also said that villages are divided through caste, class and power. 3. Status Quo and stagnant view MN Srinivas through Sanskritisation explained the fluidity and mobility in caste system. Andre Beteille also explains with more employment, British influence, the stratification system of villages is changing. 4. Religious life and caste system These are important in villages but new parameters like dominant castes (MN Srinivas), class (Andre Beteille) are also becoming important and deciding the power distribution. 5. Community life The community life of villages is also being undermined by the influence of administration and employment. Andre Beteille argued that Brahmins of Tanjore village seek employment outside village.

However AR Desai believes that there is exploitative class structure in Indian villages. The self sufficiency and little republics is true upto an extent according to him. According to Dipankar Gupta the traditional social reality of villages is breaking down with breakage of twin shakles of village (Agriculture and caste system).

Hence the self sufficient, peaceful and unified view of Indian villages by Britishers was criticised by many scholars.