Topper Copies

A State Government in the northeastern part of the country has launched a series of anti-encroachment drives across forest areas, wetlands, and revenue lands. Under the directions of the Chief Minister, the administration has intensified efforts to reclaim public land, particularly in areas reserved for ecological protection and critical infrastructure development. Most of the time, these actions have been backed by court orders and have resulted in the recovery of thousands of hectares of land. However, in certain regions, the implementation of such drives is fraught with social and political complexities. In several districts, settlements have existed for decades and are inhabited by marginalized communities with limited access to legal rights or formal rehabilitation measures. These areas are often politically sensitive and influenced by local leaders and pressure groups. Simanta is posted as Additional Deputy Commissioner (ADC) in one such district. Over the past year, the district administration has attempted to align eviction measures with welfare outreach, including the provision of temporary shelters, relocation assistance, and public consultations. Recently, a major operation was scheduled to clear encroachments from over 140 hectares of forest land within a Reserved Forest, primarily to curb rising instances of human-elephant conflict and to restore ecological balance. Anticipating eviction, some residents approached the High Court seeking a stay. However, the court refused to grant it and directed the administration to proceed with the eviction following due process. Notices were served, and a detailed roadmap was prepared to carry out the operation, which was expected to last 2-3 days due to the scale and remote location. On the first day, Simanta led a team comprising forest officials, municipal workers, and police personnel. Demolitions were conducted peacefully and without major resistance. However, on the second day, when the team returned to the site, a large group of agitated residents, primarily women and children, had gathered. They raised slogans and formed human chains to prevent further evictions. The atmosphere grew tense when some individuals began throwing stones, resulting in serious injury to a municipal worker. The crowd grew increasingly volatile and emotionally charged, demanding an immediate halt to the operation. The police contingent present on the ground was outnumbered by the crowd. Faced with this crisis, some team members pleaded with Simanta to call off the operation, fearing threats to their life and the possibility of a violent escalation. Simanta attempted to contact his superior officer (the Deputy Commissioner), but due to poor mobile connectivity in the forested area, communication could not be established. Meanwhile, several local journalists had arrived and begun reporting on the incident. Simanta is in a dilemma as to what to do. a. Evaluate the options available with Simanta to cope with the situation. b. Which of the above options would be the most appropriate for Simanta and why? c. What are the ethical dilemmas being faced by Simanta? d. Examine the qualities of a public servant which will be required to manage such situations.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

This case study reflects the current anti-encroachment drives being carried out in many areas, reflecting a conflict between law & duty v/s marginalised people. It presents issues for officers like Simanta.

a) Options and Evaluation

1) Carry out eviction

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | a) Follows her 'duty' (Kantian ethics) | a) People won't allow -> crisis for her | | b) Ensure good precedent in media | b) Hurt social contract | | c) Sets right examples for others to follow | c) Rights of marginalised groups (women & children) | | d) Ecological benefit | d) Hurt lives | | e) Rule of Law | |

2) Stop the drive

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | a) Adhering to her officers' demands | a) Wrong precedent -> slippery slope | | b) Saving lives of all | b) Media :- reporting about failure | | c) Protecting marginal communities | c) Duty failure -> crisis of conscience |

b) Simanta must follow the first option of carrying out the anti-encroachment drive, but ensure clear communication with protestors and proper legal functioning, without hurting people.

Why:

a) Rule of Law principle demand legal > anyone b) Ecological balance -> long term benefits c) Administrative duty and court's order d) Theory of double effect (Aquinas) -> one action for larger good > harm to smaller one.

c) Ethical dilemmas:

- Vulnerable sections v/s living in those areas | Reserved forest & their sanctity - Rights to shelter of people | Anti-encroachment on govt. lands - Empathy towards weaker section | Duty bound work - Human concern of living shelters | Ecological concern of forest preservation - Fulfilling orders | Leniency for children & women - Saving my team | Adhering to duty - Creating a deterrence for future | Saving present

d) Qualities:

1. Emotional intelligence to manage crowd emotion 2. Social skills to communicate stances 3. Fortitude to not be fearful of such situations 4. Innovativeness to manage such situations effectively 5. Leadership for ethical, rule bound work 6. Integrity & duty dedication 7. Inner conviction about what is right & wrong