Is caste giving way to class in India, or do the two remain intertwined? (10 marks)
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
Caste is an endogamous group, with a common name and association to an occupation. Its reality lies in "Jati".
Whereas class has an industrial origin, says TB Bottomore. It is based on access to and control over forces of production (FOP).
Caste-class nexus 1. Scholars like GD Berreman consider that caste and power (class) are not two distinct entities but two sides of the same coin. He criticises Louis Dumont on the separation and independence of class and caste. 2. Marxist scholar Kathleen Gough says that class and caste have synchronised themselves, in her study of Kumbapetta village. She shows agrarian caste and class structure coincide: big bourgeoise farmer = high caste, landless farmer = low caste. 3. KL Varghese also says that caste-based oppression provides for class-based oppression. He says caste acts as a springboard for class oppression, leading to dominance of a few. 4. Daniel Thorner also puts through his classification of Malik, Kisan, Mazdoor corresponding to caste (high, low).
Caste-class opposition 1. Louis Dumont says that they are distinct: class and power are independent of caste (such as a king's status being lower than a Brahmin's). 2. Andre Beteille, through an interactional approach, says that class-caste inequalities have now been dispersed, not cumulative (in his Sripuram village study). 3. While caste is a rigid institution, offering less mobility, class offers higher mobility.
Thus, though caste and class are different entities, the process via secularisation and urbanisation has now blurred caste, and class is on the rise.