How do sociologists like AM Shah, IP Desai and Paul Kolenda understand the structural and functional variation of the Indian family? (10 marks)
Aishwaryam Prajapati, AIR 10, 2023
GP Murdock defines family as a social unit consisting of 2 individuals of opposite sex, having sexual relation, child bearing, economic cooperation and common residence.
Family, in India, is valued so much that every deity in Hinduism is depicted with family. AM Shah and Pauline Kolenda broke the myth that family is a static institution.
AM Shah's typology 1. AM Shah, in his study of Jahomabad (Gujarat), says that family is to be seen in terms of orientation towards functions and obligation 2. He says a family may be structurally nuclear but functionally joint
Thus a family is joint or nuclear by virtue of progression or succession - Progression: child birth, marriage, adoption - Succession: death, separation, migration
IP Desai, in his study of Mahuva village, says that degree of kinship defined family. 1. 0 degree of jointness = Nuclear family (60%) 2. Some degree of jointness = Mutual fulfilment of obligation 3. Highest degree of jointness = A joint family (10%)
Paul Kolenda says that there is a cyclical variation, such as
| Patrilocal | Neolocal | Patrilocal | |---|---|---| | Joint family | Nuclear family | Joint family |
Thus the changing nature of family has made "Household" a new concept, a dwelling unit more important for analysis.