Write a short note on each of the following in not more than 150 words. (e) Distinguish between the 'book view' and 'field view' of the Indian caste system.
Yaksh Chaudhary, AIR 6, 2021
Early British scholars and Administrators like- Hutton, Max muller etc. gave their view of indian caste system.
later Ghurye and Louis Dumont presented their view from indological perspective which involved Book View.
| Book view of Indian Villages | Field view | |---|---| | 1. Isolated and self sufficient villages of India called little republics. Caste System contributed to self sufficiency. | MN SRINIVAS argued that villages have connections outside village. Hence they are not isolated | | 2. Village patriotism is present based on caste system. | occasional Village patriotism based on caste (MN Srinivas and FG. Bailey) | | 3. mobility not possible. (LOUIS DUMONT, GHURYE) | mobility can be there. MN SRINIVAS gave concept of sanskritisation to prove this | | 4. Hierarchical System. | Stratificational System. | | 5. Based on Value system (GHURYE), purity and pollution (LOUIS DUMONT) | stratification can be based on other secular factors apart from ritual factors. |
ANDRE BETEILLE says Class, Caste and power defines stratification. MN SRINIVAS says dominant caste based on secular parameters.
Hence both field view and book view present different pictures of caste system.