Limiting the country's fiscal deficit is a cherished goal, but the progress towards it is full of hurdles. In this perspective, evaluate the effectiveness of India's fiscal consolidation framework. Also examine the role of a fiscal council in enforcing fiscal discipline.
Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025
Definition Fiscal deficit is the difference between the total expenditure and total revenue (excluding debt creating receipts) of the government.
Fiscal deficit of 3% is good but in current scenario fiscal deficit has remained around 6%.
Hurdles in limiting fiscal deficit 1. Poor tax base & tax evasion. 2. Corruption 3. High expenditure of government on defence, law and order. 4. Higher investments by government as lesser investments observed from private sectors. (crowding out occurs & hence interest rate increases more) 5. Decrease in demand. 6. Disinvestments by the government or asset monetization also create negative impact and so government do not use it extensively.
India's fiscal consolidation framework Effectiveness: (A) Yes - External debt is low. - Most of the debt is internal debt (via G-securities) - Most of the borrowings are from World Bank etc. at low rate of interest. - Deficit because of government's capital expenditure which will help in growth
(B) No - Huge expenditure on defence - Not able to achieve the desired target of FD of 3% of GDP. - Government not able to fulfill its day to day expenditures because of poor tax base. - Off budget financing (FCI), withdrawal from National Small Saving observed.
Role of fiscal council - It independently assesses the fiscal policy of the government. - CAG audits the report after expenditures are made but fiscal council assesses regularly. - It helps in keeping government accountable. - Medium term macroeconomic framework is submitted to Fiscal council which can then give suggestions to government time to time.
Arguments against fiscal council 1. RBI, CAG already exist. An additional body to look after fiscal framework. 2. Reports of fiscal council are not debated and demanded in the Parliament.
Limited fiscal deficit is a necessary for good health of the economy. It minimizes borrowings and improves the image of economy in the eyes of credit rating agencies & hence promotes investment.