Discuss the 'Doctrine of Essentiality' referred to by the courts in the context of religious practices in India. (Answer in 250 words)
Vaibhavi Agrawal, AIR 35, 2025
Our constitution gives us right to religion (Article 25). However to ensure that a right to religion doesn't hamper basic rights, the doctrine of essentiality is made.
Doctrine of Essential Religious Practices
1. Supreme court in Shirur Mati 1954 case devised this doctrine. 2. It means that practices which were there during the birth of religion are considered as essential and at core of religion, are protected under Article 25. 3. Other practices which are evolved with time and hamper human rights are not protected under Article 25. Example: Tandav dance is not essential religious practice of Ananda Margi faith. Example: In Shayara bano case 2017 supreme court upheld that triple talaq is not essential religious practice and hence unconstitutional and void.
Importance of Doctrine
1. It gives justice to people who are affected by injustice due to their religion beliefs. 2. To ensured that on the name of Article 25, people dont violate other fundamental rights. 3. It gave justice to many women who often suffered from discrimination in their religion. Example: Sabari Mala Temple case: SC upheld that not allowing women into their temple is not essential to the religion. Hence women can enter the temple 4. The doctrine upheld that constitution is above all religion, hence promoting rule of law.
Challenges to the doctrine
1. When devised it was devised to distinguish between matters of religion from non religious matters, however today it is used in a theological way by judges. 2. There is requirement to amend discriminatory personal laws or religious laws rather than giving justice on case basis 3. Critics see this as overstepping of judiciary into theological matters in which they are not expert.
Doctrine of essentiality is important tool to judge upon cases. However to ensure the human dignity, religious practices should be judged based upon values of equality, dignity and freedom.