Topper Copies

Discuss the reasons for the limited success of Panchayati Raj Institutions in India. Also, recommend measures to strengthen the functioning of these institutions.

Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025

73rd Constitutional Amendment act provided for establishing the Panchayati Raj institutions in alignment with M.K. Gandhi's idea of Gram Swaraj as enshrined in Article 40 (Village Panchayats).

Success of PRIs 1. People's Participation Eg: Kerala's People's Plan 2. Providing grassroot leaders Eg: Chavi Rajawat, Fatima Beevi 3. Providing services for welfare Eg: Mission Bhagiratha by Telangana for piped water supply. 4. Grassroot development Eg: Anandhara in West Bengal empowers SHGs.

Despite success, certain reasons limit functioning of PRIs

1. Issues related to funds 1. Financially unviable. Eg: less than 1% revenue of PRIs is their own; rest is grants. 2. MFIs, banks are unwilling to lend. 3. Limited tax base and lack of trained workers for tax collection. 4. Expenditure issue: CAG reports highlight that only 29% of the funds are used for development projects. 2. Tussle between PRI functionaries and bureaucracy. 3. Lack of infrastructure Eg: 25% of the Panchayats lack basic infra -> office buildings, internet connection etc. 4. Socio-cultural hurdles rendering women participation ineffective. Eg: Mani Shankar Aiyar calls Panchayati Raj as Sarpanch Raj (Pradhan Patis and Sarpanch Patis exist). 5. Lack of effective devolution of funds & authority by state governments. 6. State Finance Commission is not constituted at regular intervals. 7. Bypassing of Gram Sabha in decision making. Eg: Sand mining case in M.P. 8. Lack of capacity building; presence of parastatal bodies. 9. Digital illiteracy

Measures to strengthen PRIs

1. Capacity building of youth & women. Eg: Panchayat Mahila evam Yuva Sashaktikaran Abhiyan. 2. Establish a dedicated cadre for PRI 3. Establishing regulatory oversight to look into function of Gram Sabhas. 4. Use of digital tools. Eg: e-Gram Swaraj 5. Effective devolution of funds and authority by state government.

Mani Shankar Aiyar committees recommendations must be implement to establish grassroots democracy & ensure democratic decentralization