Topper Copies

Right to freedom of speech and expression in India is both broad in interpretation and conditional in application. Discuss.

Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025

Article 19(1)(a) provides for both freedom of speech and expression to the citizens of the country.

After Article 21, Article 19(1)(a) is the second most interpreted right among all FR's.

Broad in interpretation 1. Right to peaceful strike is form of speech and expression. 2. Right to silence is also incorporated in Article 19(1)(a). 3. Expression of discontent or constructive criticism is allowed under Article 19(1)(a). 4. Right to hoist flag in the private spaces was allowed as it is a medium of expression of patriotism towards the country. 5. Participation in sports is also considered an integral part of Article 19(1)(a). 6. Freedom of speech and expression is also protected outside the country. 7. Right to internet is also considered a part of freedom of speech and expression & so in Anuradha Bhasin case -> court ruled against blanket ban on internet shutdown. 8. Right to information is also a part of Article 19(1)(a) (electoral bonds discontinued).

Article 19(1)(a) is conditional in application

1. Freedom of speech and expression is not absolute rather there are reasonable restrictions: 1. Public order 2. Decency or morality 3. Freindly relations with nations. 4. Incitement to an offence 5. Sovereignity 6. Defamation 7. Contempt of court 2. Censorship rules are prevalent that restrict freedom of speech and expression 3. Also IT Act (2000) allows taking down harmful content. 4. Also, Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita has offences related to hate speech.

This Article 19 is a crucial F.R. that protects citizens' right to express freely with a balance of maintaining decency.