"The collegium system has become a victim of its own success, with the concentration of power in the hands of a few, leading to questions about its legitimacy." Comment. (Answer in 150 words)
Vaibhavi Agrawal, AIR 35, 2025
Article 124 and 217 of constitution defines the appointment of higher judiciary judges that is supreme court and high court judges.
Supreme court (SC) through judges cases evolved a collegium system (SC Advocaty on records case (1993)).
Shortcomings of collegium system
1. The process is not transparent and involves the discretion of a judiciary in appointing judges for itself. 2. Minutes of the meet are not published 3. There is no reason provided for recommendation of any candidate. 4. The process is considered as closed door affairs, with no advise from any outsider like legislative or executive.
99th constitutional Amendment Act 2014 introduced a commission to select and recommend judges. However SC struck it down as unconstitutional, as it was hampering the independence of judiciary.
Solution
1. Making the process of recommendation more transparent by highlighting the reasonings for selection. 2. Suggestion from experts, Bar council, Law minister, leader of opposition etc. 3. Documenting the necessary requirement and standards for selection.
Judiciary's independence is required to ensure rule of law. However it is equally important for judiciary to be transparent about its administrative processes.