Topper Copies

The Indian Constitution does not follow the doctrine of separation of powers in its strictest sense; instead, it adopts a model based on 'checks and balances'. Elucidate.

Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025

The Indian Constitution is sui-generis that unlike USA, did not adopt strict separation of powers rather adopted a model of check and balance.

Separation of powers - Article 79 -> Parliament - Article 107-117 -> functioning of legislature - Article 50 -> separation of executive from judiciary - Article 74 read with Article 53 talk about Council of ministers and President -> The executive - Article 121/211 -> the conduct of judges cannot be discussed in Parliament.

But Indian Constitution has certain functional overlap along with mechanisms to ensure checks and balances.

Functional overlap - Legislature & executive: Every minister is an MP; delegated legislation, Presidential assent to the bills - Executive & judiciary: Tribunals, Pardoning powers of President (Article 72), judicial activism - Legislature & judiciary: Parliament's power to punish for breach of privilege, Judicial activism

Checks & Balances 1. Legislature checking executive - Question hour, use of Parliamentary committees, No-confidence motion, Adjournment motion, censure motion all ensure executive is in check. 2. Executive checking legislature - President's veto power, dissolution, summon or prorogation of house by the President. 3. Executive checking judiciary - President determining number of judges in High court, removal of judges. 4. Judiciary checking executive - Judicial review, judicial activism, matter related to elections of President can be taken up only in Supreme Court. 5. Legislature checking judiciary - Parliament setting number of judges in Supreme Court, impeachment of judges 6. Judiciary checking legislature - Article 13, basic structure doctrine, due process of law, judicial review and judicial activism.

Therefore, Indian Constitution aptly adopted the mechanism of checks & balances to ensure that no organ establishes its tyranny thereby establishing the democracy in its true sense.