Topper Copies

Why were the Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP) made non-justiciable despite being fundamental to the governance of the country?

Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025

Article 36-51 in Part IV of the Constitution incorporates the DPSP as mentioned in GoI Act, 1935 as Instrument of Instructions to build a welfare state.

Despite being fundamental, DPSPs were made non-justiciable as: 1. Post independence, India as nation state lacked economic resources and human resources for their implementation. 2. The prime objective after independence was integration of India by having agreements with more than 500 princely states. - Making DPSPs justiciable would have made the concept of privy purse in conflict with Article 39(c) -> prevent concentration of wealth. 3. India adopted a mixed economy and so DPSPs which are highly socialist in nature were made non-justiciable. 4. Consensus building for making them justiciable was very difficult. 5. India also lacked the human capacity to tackle litigations. 6. Accomodation of cultural diversity would have been in conflict with Article 44 -> UCC

DPSPs are like pole star which guide the legislature to work for the establishment of welfare state.