Topper Copies

"The Indian Constitution is a carbon copy of the Government of India Act, 1935." Comment.

Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025

The British government passed the Government of India Act, 1935 which provided for certain features that were incorporated by the Constituent Assembly in framing Indian Constitution.

Indian Constitution -> Carbon Copy of GoI Act, 1935

1. Division of powers - GoI Act provided for Centre, Provincial lists for dividing powers between federal and provinces which is encapsulated in Article 246 and Schedule 7 of the Constitution. 2. Bicameral legislature as provided in the Act is adopted at both levels - Centre and state. 3. Public service commission - As mentioned in GoI Act, 1935, Indian Constitution too incorporated Union and state public service Commission (Article 315-323). 4. Emergency provisions have also been taken from the GoI Act, 1935 (Article 352-360) 5. The Office of Governor is a modified version as mentioned in GoI Act, 1935. 6. Providing residuary powers to the Centre has also been borrowed.

However, certain features of Constitution are not borrowed from GoI Act, 1935: 1. Fundamental Rights (Article 14-32) 2. Even the universal adult franchise (Article 325 & 326) is sui-generis as GoI Act provided limited franchise with separate electorate. 3. India as a sovereign, democratic, republic is also not taken from the Act.

Hence, it can be said the GoI Act, 1935 provided for certain inspiration in making of Constitution.