Topper Copies

A case study on an official under pressure to hush up a crime case involving Rahul, son of an influential family, asking for the options available, the course of action to be adopted, and what Rahul's father's conduct reveals.

Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024

This case study is a mockery of the state of crime & law/order in our country, where punishment depends on how much rich or poor you are.

[diagram: Stakeholders - local politicians, Media/SP, Society at large, Justice?, Rahul, family]

Options

Option 1: hush up matter, manipulate evidence

Merits: I get good posting, politicians happy, matter is resolved

Demerits: Justice denied, innocent person made victim

Option 2: Slow down case and get a transfer in the next due promotion, thus evading decision-making

Merits: I get saved, onus falls on someone else

Demerits: Non-performance of duty is corruption, case goes on, so does protest

Option 3: expedite matter, seek proper evidence, if Rahul is culprit take actions against him

Course of Action

1. I will expedite inquiry 2. Investigate with evidences and frame a chargesheet 3. Against pressure: will show courage & fortitude, I will not bow down 4. Launch inquiry against those who manipulated the case 5. "Justice will be seen to be done" too in my regime

Justification: Justice approach by Plato asks us to uphold the highest values of courage, wisdom and moderation. This would be my approach to instill justice in my city for the welfare of society.

Action of Rahul's Father

1. Teaches Rahul & others to find short-cuts 2. Evils of bribery & corruption 3. Escaping societal norms of justice, responsibility 4. Hampering rule of law, constitutional morality 5. Erosion of ethics in society

"If we fail to uphold the rights, we shall prepare our suitcase to hell" - Martin Luther King Jr.