Topper Copies

A case study on a demolition drive against encroachments that will push those at the bottom of the pyramid into greater poverty, asking for the ethical issues involved, whether the drive is justified, and the measures to manage the fallout.

Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024

This case study questions the logic of a demolition drive where those at the bottom of the pyramid will face more poverty & limited means to survive.

[diagram: Stakeholders - political/civil society leaders, NGOs/activists, community, environment, administration]

My Vision: protect them with limited means & in sync with environment protection

Ethical Issues

1. Displacement due to demolition 2. Collusion/corruption allegation: that some settled with bribes to administrators 3. Loss of Sarvodaya ("welfare of all") & Antyodaya ("welfare of the last individual") 4. "Rights of Rivers" as a legal right per the Supreme court's verdict, which is violated 5. Welfare state ethics compromised

Justified

- What is development if the poor are mislaid? - What is the point of pushing out the poor when the state failed to implement its own guidelines? - Burden on state to rehabilitate - More would be involved in crime/joblessness, disaster burden etc. - Long-term loss of life, pushed down the drain

Not Justified

- Environment protection is the need of the hour - Illegal dwellings are not recognized under law - The state can't be seen to be weak in implementing its orders - Violation of existing laws - Report: encroachment would result in a drinking water crisis

So, the administration is correct going ahead.

Measures to manage

1. Implementation of laws - stop encroachment at first place 2. Alternative housing/shelter facilities to demolition victims 3. Commercial interest/livelihood issues Eg self-employment scheme 4. Safety of women/children: education, health, nutrition 5. Long-term strategy to protect rivers & environment

Development of Mother Earth = Environment ethics + Stewardship ethics