A case study on an official weighing a real-estate giant's proposal that would displace a coastal community, asking for the options available and the course of action to be adopted.
Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024
For India, approximately 15 crore people have suffered displacement, and this case study asks us to strive for a balance so that no more Indian citizens are displaced from their homes.
[diagram: Stakeholders - Coastal Community, Meas Chairman, aquatic habitat, Society at large, Real-estate giant]
My Vision: "What is development, if people suffer?"
Options
Option 1: Do as the real-estate giant proposed
| Merits | Demerits | | --- | --- | | I get wealthy by cheap property | Villagers displaced | | Mutually beneficial deal | Pressure from community |
Option 2: Work out a compromise with the real-estate giant
| Merits | Demerits | | --- | --- | | Deal is still done so I get wealthy | Some sort of integrity compromise | | Real-estate giant might agree | Coastal community still at risk |
Option 3: Deny doing what is asked
| Merits | Demerits | | --- | --- | | Coastal community protected | Transfer/career compromise; pressure from above | | Environmental balance maintained | Project might get halted, development compromised |
Option 4: Study the DPR; if a shift of highway is possible without hurting communities or harming environment, then do it
| Merits | Demerits | | --- | --- | | Real estate guy happy | Long-term villagers affected | | Project gets a head-on | Integrity & probity still compromised |
Option 5: Stick to the initial DPR, file a complaint against the real-estate guy for bribe offering, proceed with rules & guidelines
| Merits | Demerits | | --- | --- | | Conscience is heard | Pressure from above | | Coastal community & environment protected | Threat to life; career compromise |
Course of Action
A mix of Option 3 & Option 5, which would lead to the DPR being worked out.
1. Coastal community's livelihood & habitation is protected 2. Real-estate giant is respected and no loss of probity 3. Development is balanced with environment
Justification: My idea is that pressure would always be there, but with integrity, probity and fortitude we need to cross these muddy waters.