Topper Copies

While some argue that values are influenced by temporal and situational factors, others uphold the belief in timeless & universal human values. What is your opinion in this regard? Justify your answer.

Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024

"Be a man of value" said Albert Einstein, signifying the importance of values for us.

Influence - Temporal/Situational

1. Experience of lifetime - like Gandhi's shift to civil-disobedience 2. Constantly evolving learning - like when placed in situation of development vs. environment protection, value of Golden Mean (Aristotle) comes to rescue 3. Values inculcated by reading books/watching cinema Eg like Satyajit Ray's - Pather Panchali: value of poverty as evil 4. Taught to us by episodic events Eg SC Bose - resignation from ICS after seeing atrocities - value of patriotism

Timeless/Universal values

1. Non-violence: Jainism, Buddhism to Gandhian ethics 2. Truth & Honesty: Ramayana to PM Modi's Pariksha Pe Charcha highlights it 3. Helping poor: Nanak said "sharing your earning with others" (Sufism) 4. Value of respecting elders 5. Celebrating festivals, customs Eg Rakshabandhan: gender equality, timeless bond

Thus, I believe, values are a mix of timeless wisdom & situational factors to make us "good politicians": social animal with hearts.