"In the realm of International relations, ethics often takes a backseat to national interest, which primarily drives foreign policy decisions." Critically examine.
Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024
"There is no place for ethics or morality in International relations" - Hans J. Morgenthau.
Thus, the above quote points how ethics are backseated in global relations.
Eg Israel's declaration of war on Palestine - Immediate interest: to protect people - Hidden interest: to exterminate Gaza
National interest > ethics in IR
1. Narrow self-interest: like Pakistan stopping construction of dams by India as per Indus Water Treaty, benefits to millions of people but NO! 2. Power-mongering: like China's claims (Megalomania) in South China Sea 3. Loss of humanitarian approach: like developed nations not giving TRIPS waiver to COVID-19 vaccine manufacturing for developing world 4. To put down others: like China's building [string] of pearls against India 5. Failure of Collective Vision: reflected in WTO - non-resolvement of agriculture, dispute settlement issues
However, ethics > national interest
1. Stance reversal: India condemning Israel (Sheikh Jarrah evictions) & Russia (Bucha killings) despite it being traditional allies 2. Management of Global commons: Arctic Council, Antarctic Treaty 3. Resolving problem without Passports: like climate change 4. Humanitarian aid: like 3 trillion to Afghanistan by India 5. Recent, G-7 Global Compact to help developing world
Globally, we need to multilaterally engage to establish what Aristotle called the "Eudaimonia" - a happy place.