The balance between laws & conscience is delicate; when synchronised, they promote ethical conduct, but their discord can give rise to significant ethical dilemmas. Illustrate with examples.
Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024
"In matters of conscience, the law of majority has no prevail"... - Gandhi.
However, law & conscience share a delicate relationship.
Ethical conduct when synchronised
1. Moral decision making: Eg when [law] says to uproot tribals for development but [conscience] says to place them, synchronization: rehabilitate them 2. Resolves crisis of conscience: when in dilemma due to lack of decision reaching ability 3. Upholds professional & religious integrity: - Law: to promote beef industry - Conscience: Jain officer against - synchronization: "seva to jiva is seva to Siva" (thus, public service given primacy) 4. Resolves Know-Do conflict as said by Dayanand Saraswati Eg encroachment vs. livelihood loss
Discord - ethical dilemmas
1. Law - build roads, cut trees; Conscience - environment ethics compromised [ethical dilemma] 2. Deontologically sound decisions not made: often decisions made are not morally justifiable 3. Issue of individual conscience: Eg whether to give capital punishment or not 4. Ineffective judgments/decisions
Thus, Gandhi said: to align to the spirit of service & even challenging laws which hurt human at its core.