Topper Copies

Do you agree with the utilitarian principle that "the greatest happiness of the greatest no." should guide decision-making and public policy formulation?

Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024

Utilitarianism (Jeremy Bentham) puts emphasis on "greatest happiness of greatest number" as maxim for social life.

Eg capital punishment to rapists lead to peace in hearts of people in society.

In Agreement

1. Social legitimacy is given by this doctrine - Eg humanitarian intervention in Palestine by UN-body 2. Voices of majority heard & by policy-making for the maximum - Eg Indian democracy model 3. In consonance with public welfare: public welfare demands greatest happy population - Eg MGNREGA/PDS - benefits to more people 4. Ethical framework: Bentham said: "State comes into being for welfare of the majority"

In dis-agreement

1. Marginalises minority: their voice is marginalised Eg India - FPTP majority govt., minority votes (no value) 2. Is-ought: Utilitarianism is pleasure seeking but true development of individuals hindered 3. Amartya Sen: In India, poverty/inequality are issues which can't be sidelined 4. Decision making & public policy should listen to the poor

Gandhiji: when in delusion, remember the face of poor & what your actions would do to it.