Topper Copies

Q.12) You are appointed as an officer heading the Air Quality Compliance Division of the Environment Pollution Control Board in Delhi-NCR. The region is witnessing alarming levels of air pollution, which typically worsen during the winter months due to various meteorological and anthropogenic factors. The situation has led to severe public health concerns, particularly affecting vulnerable groups such as the elderly, children, and those with respiratory illnesses. The Supreme Court has also raised serious concern over the deteriorating air quality in Delhi-NCR and has directed the administration to take immediate and effective measures to control pollution, especially during the winter months. Your jurisdiction has a large number of small and medium-scale industries that were granted environmental clearance over the years. These industries form the backbone of the local economy and provide employment to a significant number of migrant workers. However, recent inspections and air quality monitoring reports indicate that a significant number of these units are operating in violation of prescribed air emission norms. As part of targeted measures to curb air pollution, you issued notices to all identified polluting units, directing them to apply for fresh environmental clearance certificates from the competent authority. However, your decision triggered strong opposition from a section of industrial units, labour unions, and local politicians. Industrial owners argued that such action would lead to production shutdowns, financial losses, and shortages of their products in the market. Labour unions and workers also protested, fearing mass unemployment and livelihood insecurity. Local politicians and vested interests accused you of jeopardising the socio-economic stability of the region. You received representations from various quarters urging you to withdraw the notices and not initiate harsh measures, citing the interests of multiple stakeholders. Additionally, you began receiving anonymous threats, aimed at coercing you into reversing your decision. On the other hand, several of your colleagues supported your stance, encouraging you to act in the larger public interest. Several local NGOs and environmental groups rallied behind your actions, demanding the immediate closure of polluting units. a. Under the given conditions, what are the options available to you? b. Critically evaluate each of the options listed by you. c. What are the ethical dilemmas being faced by you?

Mayank Purohit, AIR 33, 2025

The above case deals with the issue of conflict between environment protection and local economic needs.

(c.) Ethical Dilemmas

1. Environmental protection by reviewing clearances vs Economic needs of the area. 2. Doing my duty of pollution control vs Interests of Industrial units. 3. Personal consequences (threats received) vs official/professional duty. 4. Upholding principles of Environment Ethics vs Giving in to political pressure 5. Health of local population vs Livelihood of workers if Industries closed. 6. Upholding court orders vs public anger and protests. 7. Interests of NGOs and activists vs Interests of migrant workers.

(a.) + (b.) Options available and evaluation

Option 1: Go ahead with reviewing clearances and ensure compliance Merits 1. Environmental pollution reduced 2. Duty fulfilled. Demerits 1. May lead to more anger. 2. Personal safety (threats) compromised.

Option 2: Leave the position and seek transfer Merits 1. No personal consequence 2. No safety issue and harm. Demerits 1. Pollution may continue. 2. Sets bad precedent of using coercion

Option 3: Abandon the process to enable economic wellbeing. Merit 1. Economic wellbeing and livelihoods secured 2. No political pressure. Demerits 1. Pollution of air 2. Health of vulnerable sections compromised 3. Duty not fulfilled

Option 4: Review clearances and give time to ensure compliance. Help by arranging expertise to enable transition to low polluting processes. Merit 1. Reduces pollution. 2. Health of people will be better 3. Duty fulfilled. Demerits 1. May cause delays. 2. Costs may be imposed on industries.

In situations such as these a fine balance between development needs and environment must be envisaged without compromising long term good.