Topper Copies

Despite multiple resolutions and initiatives undertaken by the United Nations Security Council (UNSC), its efforts to counter terrorism have achieved limited success. Discuss the reasons for this limited effectiveness. (Answer in 150 words)

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

Recent Op Sindoor, Pahalgam attacks highlight the menace of state sponsored terrorism. At the same time, global ignorance to the issue highlights failure of UNSC order to tackle it.

UNSC resolutions & initiatives 1. UN Counter Terrorism Committee 2. UNSC resolution 1267 and 2412 3. On paper ideas like freezing assets, no travel for designated terrorist

Reasons for limited success 1. Lack of definition of terrorism - State sponsored, by Pakistan - Religious, by Al Qaeda (eg LWE), ideology 2. Overlap with right to self determination and thus misuse 3. Realpolitik: China blocked 'Masood Azhar' designation for long (no moral behaviour) 4. Issue of veto -> creates undue influence 5. Differential approach: US thinks it's sporadic, India thinks it is continuous 6. No distinction today (eg Taliban are terrorists & rulers; similarly HTS in Syria) 7. Issues with UN Charter -> Nicaragua ruling & difficult to prove State & Non-State link 8. Difficult to prove terrorism (eg what's civil war in Myanmar, terrorism for Junta) 9. Failure of dialogue & diplomacy

Way Forward 1. Comprehensive Counter Terrorism treaty 2. Terrorism as global problem. "Snakes in backyard will bite everyone" -> This seek global solution 3. T-20 by Nirupama Rao -> Global South grouping as more vulnerable

Revised policy Terror as Act of war.

"Terror is guided by fanaticism and finance is lifeblood" -> eventually it is about curbing the [line cut off at the bottom edge of the page]