What are the key objectives of the Right to Information Act, 2005? Examine the ethical concerns associated with certain provisions of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act in realizing the objectives of the RTI Act.
Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025
'Sunlight is the best disinfectant' - 2nd ARC This quote was the guiding light behind Right to Information Act 2005, hailed as Sunshine legislation.
Key objectives:
a) Mandatory disclosures (Sec 4) -> Proactive info. sharing b) Info. about govt. work to public -> Good governance c) Timely info. for scrutiny of public funds (30 days) d) Balancing secrecy & openness (Sec 8)
DPDP Act was brought to protect right of Data principles such as privacy, consent, erasure of data etc and to ensure duty and due diligence by Data fiduciary.
Ethical concerns (RTI v/s DPDP):
a) Privacy of data in DPDP v/s openness in RTI b) Protecting govt. from DPDP provisions v/s RTI's scrutiny over govt. c) Govt. secrets protected in DPDP v/s RTI focus on transparency d) People's right to know (A. 19(1)) v/s privacy rights (A 21) e) Data protection v/s Data publicity and access to common citizens
How to balance:
a) Privacy to be protected, but not in national security or RTI cases b) Strong proactive disclosure of public data (Sec 4)