(a) "2018 marks the 25th anniversary of the promised revolution in local governance". In this context, discuss to what extent urban local bodies have been able to perform effectively as vibrant democratic units of self-government.
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
The 73rd and 74th amendment to the Constitution in 1992 and 1993 paved way for decentralised administration and local governance. - They have empowered local population and representatives for decision making and services. - They have earmarked responsibility at local level, acting as "schools" for local leaders in politics. - Vora and Palshikar remark that they have changed Politics of Ideology to Politics of Representation. - The Bottom-up approach in planning has allowed the details of needs to be provided from below. - This is against the one size shoe fits all approach and allows for customisation of plans and special innovation in implementation - Reservation provisions have allowed marginalised sections like SCs, STs and women to get their voices heard. - During current Smart City programme, urban local bodies played crucial role in developing plans and ensuring viability of finance. - In Swachh Bharat ranking as well city municipal corporation are toiling hard and now also using Municipal bonds Eg Pune, Indore for Investment
But a lot of factors have kept them from realising real potential. - Devolution of finance powers from state is very low. - This has led to low equilibrium trap where poor services lead to lower taxes and in turn low accountability - The condition of local schools and health centers is not very good due to lack of funds. Eg Economic survey pointed undercollection in Jaipur, Bangalore of land taxes. - Right to City for poorer section suffers due to policy capture - Corruption in Infrastructure and public procurement breeds trust deficit and low participation - Poor Governance mechanism like lack of transparency, delay in files are roadblock to vibrancy
Hence, Area Sabhas and Ward Committees need promotion for citizen involvement. Devolution of funds must pave way for Evolution of ideas for real Cooperative - Collaborative - Constructive Federalism.