Topper Copies

Compare and contrast C.W Mills conception of elite in the power structure with that of Pareto and Mosca.

Yaksh Chaudhary, AIR 6, 2021

According to Elite theory, the power in society is captured by a minority of elites and they maintain this coercive power over the unaware masses.

1. Pareto argues that the elites have superior pyschological abilities by which they maintain their domination. Mosca on the same lines suggest that the elites have the superior organisational skills. While CW mills on the other hand attribute the elite's domination to the institutional factors.

2. Pareto and mosca argues that there is a circulation of elites in the power positions. Mosca says that there are two type of elites ie. lions and foxes. These two are in power in cyclical manner. The ruling elite (ie. either foxes or lions) loose vigour over time and are replaced by the non-governing elites. CW mills on the other hand suggest that there are some pivotal institutions in the society. America has Corporations, military and federal government as pivotal institutions. The elites capture the command positions in these pivotal organisations/institutions 3. According to Mosca, some ruling elites can also come from masses while CW mills argues that the elites from 3 pivotal institutions have same background and same socialisation, hence they share integration and solidarity with each other.

However there are some similarities also between their theories

1. Elites always rule the masses. Elites have same qualities and positions by which they dominate the passive masses. 2. Elites takes all the decisions of the society. For ex- in 1945 elites took the decision of bombing Hiroshima in Japan (CW mills) 3. The interests of masses and elites are not always same. Elite take decisions for their own interests. 4. Elites exploit the passive and unaware masses. 5. Pareto and CW mills, both argue that elites come from same background and there is elite self recruitment of the society.

However their theories are criticised on the following matters

1. Pluralists like- Robert Dahl argue that power is not concentrated in the elites but dispersed in the society. 2. Thompson criticise them that Elites do not always take decisions for their own interests but they have to give concessions to masses to maintain their domination.

Hence elite theories of Pareto, mosca, and CW mills converge on many front while diverging on other. But all argue that elites maintain domination over masses.