Topper Copies

(a) "Tradition and modernity exist in contemporary Indian society". Discuss factors responsible for such continuity and change.

Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018

According to Lloyd Rudolph, Modernity in India has been a result of Assimilation and not Replacement. This explains why the presence of traditional and modernity elements is simultaneous.

Many of the circumstances have changed in Indian context - 1. Industrialisation and Market Economy -> the occupational diversification in all fields has reduced the occupational segregation based on caste. 2. Breakdown of Jajmani relations, led to freedom of lower caste people who could take up new jobs and skills can also be freely acquired 3. Urbanisation has led to migration for Education and job opportunities. 4. Eating in hotels, travelling together, has reduced the purity-pollution aspect of caste. 5. Consumerism, Capitalist nature and Individualism - is fuelling Secularisation religion and its rituals are less followed by neolocal families. 6. The structural nuclear family is also observed due to poor capacity to sustain big family & privacy concerns 7. Democratic values, Justice and modern Education are promoting Constitutional virtues - also in political discourse where merit considerations on development are seen.

But many prospects of Indian society are still entrenched in traditional values. 1. MN Srinivas found a bulldozer driver who practices driving for livelihood but practices magic/sorcery in free time He terms this Cultural Schizophrenia. 2. According to Dipankar Gupta, Indian middle class is mistaken and this westoxicated elite has failed to accept modern values in spirit. 3. K.L Sharma remarks that this occurs due to structural inconsistencies as bureaucracy without universalism, legislation without rule of law and democratisation without education. 4. Yogindra Singh in his Modernisation schema explains that their are local syncretism and continuity as some aspects of religion & caste remain untouched by British Modernisation. 5. Andre Beteille believes that its the political class and media which sustains primordial identities & caste resilience. 6. New sects and cults indicate search for privatised religion and belief in superstitions also

Hence elements of both change and continuity coexist in Indian society and identities are reinterpreted for benefits