(c) "The Varna scheme has 'distorted' the picture of caste". Comment
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
Based on Indological perspective proposed by Ghurye, and Purushsukta doctrine, the Varna scheme was popularised to explain the evolution of caste systems
This appeared that hierarchy is fixed ritually and scholars like Dumont developed binary based on purity-pollution to explain the ideological antecedent.
But later scholars based on field work draw a difference between Varna and Jati. MN Srinivas notes the difference as varna being ideal book-view order, while jati being the reality of caste.
Dipankar Gupta puts forward the most critical perspective on this. He posits that based on several caste origin legends, he finds that most caste reason their low position due to being tricked or misunderstood. Every caste claims to have some caste below it. Hence, castes or jatis must not be seen in hierarchy of Varna, rather as distinct categories, sometimes even unrelated. These distinct jatis have independent and differentiated existence, not necessarily in hierarchy. Eg Amot caste which sacrifices pig during Gosaiya festival, Brahmins take water from them. Also Robert Diege has verified these claims that posit that Varna scheme distorts the real picture of Caste differentiation