'No society can either be absolutely open or absolutely closed.' Comment.
Yaksh Chaudhary, AIR 6, 2021
Pitrim Sorokin in his book "Socio-Cultural dynamics", 1938 argues that no society is completely closed or open. Some form of mobility and fluidity is always present.
1. The systems considered as hierarchy or closed stratification can have some form of social mobility. MN Srinivas in his study of Rampura village showed that even the closed caste system can undergo mobility through Sanskritisation and westernisation 2. With the advent of modernisation and globalisation, the social system are now open to diffusion of new ideas. Yogendra Singh showed that how a social system is affected by external and internal factors and bring structural and cultural change 3. With more industrialisation, many new classes have emerged which has made the capitalist system more open. Weber argues that expansion of middle classes is happening leading to social mobility. 4. According to Parsons, social system always go through small changes which disturbs the social equilibrium. By adapting to these destablising forces, a new equilibrium sets in. 5. Pierre Bourdieu through his fourfold classification of capital argues that one type of capital can lead to accumulation of other type. 6. Oxford social mobility study by Goldthorpe shows that social system always has some form of mobility.
Hence, social system always has scope for change and no society is completely closed or completely open.