(a) Critically examine the limitations of the structuralist-functionalist perspective in the analysis of the Indian society.
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
The Indological analysis of Indian society by Ghurye, soon paved way for Structural functionalist paradigm under influence of Robert Redfield, Evans Pritchard etc.
Village studies by MN Srinivas, SC Dube tried to adopt an anthropological approach to study village in totality. - It conceived caste as being central to the understanding of Indian society. - It did recognise some changes specially at cultural level like Modernisation, Westernisation and Sanskritisation, but failed to notice the radical changes due to British onslaught. - Functionalism sought to find a functional significance to all social institutions be it religion, caste etc. Srinivas' concept of functional unity is an eg. to analyse marriage ceremony. - The class dimensions and the economic consciousness was not captured which had dialectical nature - It led to tautologies & teleologies to justify norms and entrenched traditions. - Studies of family by Iravati Karve also reflect a functional analysis but could not capture changing impact. - It failed to explain the conflicts like Naxalism, the problems of slum areas and peasant-farmer agitation post liberalisation.
Other scholars like AR Desai has tried to use a Marxist class based approach to analyse Indian society. He not only noted the dynamism in Indian class structure due to British colonialism, but also claimed that Indian caste inheres a passive but explosive class character. And Indian state is capitalist in ideology and reality.
Andre Beteille used Weberian perspective to account for dimensions of power and status as well.
Though these ideas have supplemented understanding of Indian society, structural functionalism saw society as it was and was the pioneering approach of Indian sociologists.