While decriminalization of politics is crucial, it is equally important to balance it with principles of justice, fairness, and the presumption of innocence to ensure the elimination of any doubt regarding political persecution of the opposition. In this perspective, discuss the necessity of decriminalization of politics and the challenges therein. Also assess the role of judiciary in furthering the cause of clean politics.
Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025
Decriminalization of politics in current scenario as gained importance because according to Association for Democratic Reforms, around 44% of MP in current Lok Sabha have criminal background.
Necessity of decriminalization 1. Check on tyranny of executive and legislature: MP or MLAs with criminal background are an hindrance in the development. Citizens rights are violated because of such criminal people. 2. Maintainenance of trust in the citizens: Decriminalisation of politics ensures trust in citizens. 3. Effective policies: People with criminal background cannot make effective decisions for the betterment of citizens. 4. Strengthening of democracy.
Challenges in decriminalization 1. No provision of debarring candidates having any criminal background. 2. Limited powers to ECI for punishing the violators. They (ECI) can only give warnings. 3. People (citizens) are swayed away by the caste & religion tactics used by criminal politicians. 4. Money and muscle power of criminal politicians escapes them from convictions by judiciary. Ex: Bhushan Singh case.
Role of judiciary Judiciary at time to time has taken steps for decriminalization: - ADR vs UoI case: SC in the judgement made it mandatory for candidates to disclose their criminal background, educational qualifications so that people can make effective decisions. - PUCL case (2013): NOTA option was introduced by the SC so that people do not elect any candidate if they consider the candidate ineligible. - Common Cause Vs UoI case: Submission of election expenses was made mandatory. - Subramaniam Balaji vs State of Tamil Nadu: ECI to given powers to regulate election manifestos. - PUCL Case (2013): Introduction of VVPAT for transparency.
Decriminalization of politics is crucial for realising the true power embedded in legislature and effective for betterment of citizens, as well as country.