Topper Copies

Examine the salient features of Weberian bureaucracy. What was Weber's assessment of the increasing bureaucratization of modern societies?

Yaksh Chaudhary, AIR 6, 2021

Weber analysed the concept of Bureaucracy through the paradigm of his ideal type. According to Weber with modernisation, rationalisation will dominate in the society. Rational bureaucracy will emerge from this process of rationalisation.

Salient features of Weberian Bureaucracy

Weber formed the Ideal type of Bureaucracy:

1. Bureaucracy is an organisation where activities are rationally defined to achieve the pre defined goal of organisation. 2. Clearcut hierarchy is there where there is a chain of Command. 3. Rational system of selection of bureaucrats based on qualifications and merit. 4. Each bureaucratic office has specific task to perform and has expertise in that. Ex- Income Tax department work for taxation and involves expertise 5. The process and activities of bureaucracy works under written legal codes and rules. 6. Bureaucrats work for bureaucracy as a vocation. 7. Bureaucrats do not usurp the power or position the bureaucracy 8. It has benefits of calculability, efficient and predictability in working. 9. Rational bureaucracy is the most efficient organisation for the rational society. Hence it can't be escaped. Weber calls this iron "cage of rationality."

Weber's View on increasing bureaucratisation

According to Weber bureaucracy has the benefit of being most efficient organisation for modern society. It can fulfil the need of capitalism by providing a rational organisation for performing tasks. However Weber had some apprehensions about increasing bureaucracy:

1. Redtapism 2. Iron cage of rationality which society can't escape 3. It produces experts without soul and emotianality 4. It can lead to disenchantment and alienation 5. Rigid norms and rules can hamper achievement of goals. RK Merton calls it deviance ie. ritualism.

Criticisms and Other views on Bureaucracy

1. Burns and Stalker argue that bureaucracy is not suitable for all the industries. Industries which require flexibility are not suited for rigid bureaucracy. 2. Similarly Alvin Gouldner in his study of gypsum mines in USA argued that presence of bureaucracy hampered the productivity in the gypsum mines 3. Marxists like Bowels and Gintis suggest that bureaucracy in organisations is used to maintain the domination over the working class.

Hence Weber made the ideal type of bureaucracy by characterising it. He suggested that it is the most efficient organisation of social work. However he was also aware about the downfall and negatives of bureaucracy.